The Old Inn On The Green Restaurant

The Old Inn On The Green Restaurant

4.6 (101 reviews) Breakfast Score™ 60.6 Closed
Ad slot: restaurant

134 Hartsville-New Marlborough Rd, New Marlborough, MA 01230, USA

(413) 229-7924

http://oldinn.com/dining/menus/

Get Directions

Hours

Wednesday 5:30 - 9:00 PM
Thursday 5:30 - 9:00 PM
Friday 5:30 - 9:00 PM
Saturday 5:30 - 9:00 PM
Sunday 5:30 - 9:00 PM

Photos

Ad slot: restaurant_reviews

Reviews

  • Margo Coble
    ★ 5

    We arrived for dinner and we were immediately greeted by a hostess and seated. Our waiter was friendly and we got a complementary pre appetizer from the chef. The food was exceptional and we loved how you could order all 3 courses for one price and at once. I especially recommend the Slow Braised Angus Short Rib, the puréed parsnips were the best I’ve ever tasted. At the end, they gave us all a free cookie. Overall, I think this place is perfect for a relaxing and enjoyable night out.

  • Heather Harrison
    ★ 5

    We were absolutely overwhelmed with the 5 course dinner and wine tasting, from beginning to end. By far the best food and wine pairings we've ever experienced. Look forward to dining with them in the future.

  • Summer Wang
    ★ 5

    This has been the highlight of our Berkshires weekend gateway! A far away restaurant but definitely worth the trip. The building itself is a charming and cozy American inn decorated with lots of barrels and wooden, stylish design. My favorite touch was the fact that our candlelight dinner was served outdoor, adding to an already excellent atmosphere. Service was not notch. You can feel that everyone was enjoying the meal and all the waiters and bartenders really take pride in their skills. Regarding the food - They obviously put a lot of thought into the menu. All the dishes we tried were marvelous. It’s a 3 courses menu, with one appetizer, one main, and one dessert l. We got the salmon and cod as main dishes, with burrata and lobster pasta as first course. Everything was right on point and the drinks were also amazing. We really enjoyed the time and would love to visit again. Great job, thank you guys.

  • Niav Connor
    ★ 2

    After reading all the great reviews, my husband and I decided to try The Old Inn On The Green Restaurant for Christmas Eve dinner. I’m not sure if last night was an off night, but our experience was quite disappointing. Upon being seated, I was surprised by the menu and price, which was completely different than what was posted on their website and what we were expecting.

    The week leading up to our dinner, I had been checking the website to see if there was a special menu. The only one listed was their normal pre fix menu and price. Both my husband and I were looking forward to items that were on that menu.

    Sadly instead of that menu, they presented us with a very limited pre fix menu with options that weren’t very appealing to either of us, along with a price increase.

    At this point, I should’ve said something but the restaurant has a $50 pp cancellation fee and I was concerned we’d be charged if we left. Also it was almost 9pm.

    Unfortunately, we decided to stay. The initial disappointment about the menu, could’ve been assuaged had the food been amazing. But it wasn’t. There was nothing special about the food. It was bland to mediocre. At the price point of $350 for 2 people (we each had 1 drink), the food better be special!

    When I asked to speak with the manager (Eric) as to why the special menu and price increase weren’t listed on the website, he told me “as grateful as he was to have us dining with them, that we shouldn’t even have been allowed in that night.” What?? He went to say that “he didn’t know how we got a reservation because they had been booked for months.” Talk about gaslighting!

    The fact that I made a reservation through their reservation system has nothing to do with the restaurant’s neglect to be transparent about the menu and price change on their website. Had I seen their limited Christmas menu, I never would’ve made the reservation.

    We’ll never return and can’t recommend this restaurant. The 2 stars are for the ambience and service. Both were lovely. But not enough to make up for the ridiculously high price for such mediocre food.

  • Emma Lauerwald
    ★ 5

    Great atmosphere and they really tend to you. Drinks were great and the evening felt special.

Similar Restaurants Nearby