The Cookie Lady’s Cafe

The Cookie Lady’s Cafe

4.6 (544 reviews) Breakfast Score™ 65.4 Closed
Ad slot: restaurant

2501 NJ-88, Point Pleasant, NJ 08742, USA

(732) 714-9494

http://www.cookieladyscafe.com/

Get Directions

Hours

Monday 7:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Tuesday 7:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Wednesday 7:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Thursday 7:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Friday 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Saturday 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Sunday 7:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Photos

Ad slot: restaurant_reviews

Reviews

  • Julie Campbell
    ★ 5

    If you’re ever in the area, this place is a must-visit! It’s a small, cozy hole-in-the-wall spot with an amazing chef and a wonderful staff. Evan provided excellent service—he made sure we had everything we needed and checked on us often. Our barista, Roe, made some incredible drinks as well.

    The café was decorated for Saint Patrick’s Day, which made the atmosphere even more fun and welcoming. The food was fantastic—my son had the chicken and waffles with a cookie dough latte, and I ordered the mega meal with a chai coconut latte. Everything was fresh, delicious, and clearly made to order.

    We had a great experience and will definitely be back!

  • Meli G
    ★ 2

    The staff was extremely friendly, kind, and efficient. However, everything was dirty! When I wiped our blue sharing plate a bunch of black stuff came off and our forks had dried up pieces of food all over them. Additionally, the Banana Split French Toast was only okay. It looked great! But much of the fruit was sour and it didn't really taste like it was actually dipped in anything, certainly not with much sugar. I don't know, I heard a lot of good things about this quaint little place but left highly disappointed.

  • Holli Davila
    ★ 5

    Awesome vibe! Awesome breakfast! Super friendly nice staff! Your Definite neighborhood mom and pop place! Will definitely 💯 go back...

  • Lindsey Alexandria
    ★ 5

    I just found the cutest and coziest restaurant in Point Pleasant!

    The Cookie Lady Cafe is the place to be for homey vibes and delicious food! And if you’re looking for something fun to do, every Wednesday night they open up their doors with a special menu to have trivia night hosted by Quizzaholics! My boyfriend and I had such a great time getting competitive and investing ourselves through each round to answer each question. There’s awesome prizes for the winners!

    Their pancakes were like a a warm hug on a plate. They were thin and golden and lightly buttered with the right hint of sweetness. We added chocolate chips to ours and they added the cutest little powdered sugar flower design on them.

    The cheesesteak was monstrous in size. The gooey cheese and tender meat made this a great savory meal.

    The wings were sauced to perfection! Each wing had tons of meat and made the perfect appetizer.

    The hot honey chicken sandwich was a solid choice. The coleslaw on the sandwich really complimented the kick from the hot honey!

    Service was so friendly and attentive. It was nice trying a bit of breakfast and lunch. I definitely want to come back during their breakfast hours!

  • Suzette Sequeira
    ★ 5

    About 7 minute drive from the Jenkinson's Boardwalk and Beach in Point Pleasant.
    Opens at 7am!
    Greeted with smiles!
    Noticed sign The Cookie Lady's Cafe is under new management!
    Head Chef was greeting customers.
    Hot latte and eggs Benedict!
    Were great!
    I like my poached eggs well done- soft!
    Thank you just perfect for me!
    Fresh squeezed orange juice to go!
    Good vibes!
    Wishing you much success!

    Very clean!

    Parking on site!

Similar Restaurants Nearby